Right this moment on The Argument, policing is damaged. So how ought to we repair it?
- choose peter cahill
Members of the jury I perceive you’ve gotten a verdict.
Derek Chauvin’s been discovered responsible!
- information clip
Breaking information, former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin has been discovered responsible within the loss of life of George Floyd.
Say his title! George Floyd!
- information clip
Cellphone video of Floyd’s loss of life horrified People and galvanized a nationwide social justice motion, resulting in protests in cities throughout the nation and people requires police reform.
- vp kamala harris
A measure of justice isn’t the identical as equal justice. This verdict brings us a step nearer. We nonetheless should reform the system.
- information clip
Killed by police lower than two days after the palpable aid felt over the responsible verdict within the Chauvin trial, the Minneapolis space in mourning once more because the household of Dante Wright held his memorial service.
Final week, an anxious America awaited the jury’s resolution. Officer Derek Chauvin was convicted on all prices for the homicide of George Floyd. However no matter emotions greeted such a uncommon consequence have been short-lived for a lot of. The following day, a Virginia man named Isaiah Brown was on the cellphone with 911 police dispatch when a sheriff’s deputy shot him 10 instances, allegedly mistaking the cellphone for a gun. It looks like every single day in America, there’s a brand new title to be taught, new footage of deadly police violence to witness, one other neighborhood in mourning, pleading for change. There’s no debate right here. Policing in America is damaged. The place there may be debate, although, is the way to repair it. [MUSIC PLAYING] I’m Jane Coaston. And I don’t suppose we have to abolish the police. I do suppose we want some severe fixes, like eliminating certified immunity and having the police specializing in dwindling murder clearance charges, moderately than specializing in how greatest or how typically to wield lethal power. Right this moment, I’ve gathered three company who method reform in a different way to see the place we agree and don’t. Rashawn Ray is a fellow on the Brookings Institute and a professor of sociology on the College of Maryland. Randy Shrewsberry is a former police officer. He’s now the manager director of the Institute for Felony Justice Coaching Reform. And Ash-Lee Woodard Henderson is the primary Black lady to function co-executive director of the Highlander Analysis and Training Middle in Tennessee, a social justice coaching middle the place seminal figures like Rosa Parks skilled.
Randy, Rashawn, Ash-Lee, welcome to The Argument. And thanks a lot for becoming a member of me.
Thanks a lot for having us.
So my very own private curiosity in police reform got here from the expertise of each overpolicing and underpolicing. My father’s Black, my mom is white. And being pulled over with my dad as a result of he was driving a automotive he mustn’t have been driving, a Mazda Miata, of which he was very pleased with. However then they appear within the automotive they usually see me. And I’m carrying my ballet outfit as a result of I used to be six. And the police officer, you could possibly simply see in his face being like, that is simply silly. That is simply completely silly. However then I went to a predominantly white highschool, all woman’s Catholic highschool in Cincinnati, Ohio. And the policing they skilled was completely completely different, completely completely different, the place you’ll hear about interactions they’d have with police wherein they’d be — and I’ve written about this earlier than — they’d be downright disrespectful to police. And I believe we’ve seen that there’s an expectation on this nation of who is meant to be policed and who just isn’t speculated to be policed, that you simply’re speculated to go police these folks over there, however if you happen to order me to put on a masks, nicely, that’s simply an excessive amount of right here. And we see time and time once more that the majority killings by police begin with visitors stops, psychological well being checks, home disturbances, low degree offenses. We’ve seen with the instances of Philando Castile and others that visitors stops might be lethal. Randy, the place does this come from? Why is the deal with low degree offenses and never fixing murders? I believe lots of people suppose that the police are targeted on catching criminals, when that’s not likely what they do.
No, so I’m from Cincinnati, by the way in which. And I work simply exterior of Cincinnati as a police officer. And it was an outdated, retired police captain who was one in all our academy commanders who stated to me this. And this was a time the place I used to be a bit extra conservative than I’m right this moment. I don’t actually have a lot conservative viewpoints right this moment. However he stated no matter notions that you’ve of policing, dismiss them. That is whereas I used to be within the academy. He stated your job is to arrest the three D’s: The drunk, the drugged, and the deranged. And that shook me as a result of I assumed these are society points, proper? These are issues we will repair, as an alternative of coming behind with enforcement, proper? We will get forward of those sorts of issues. And so, through the years, what I noticed is that within the academy, we have been offered this image. Like, the world is a warfare zone, proper? Each time we step exterior, there’s going to be bullets flying over our head. The dangerous guys are all the time out to get us, these sorts of issues. After which I actually realized that it was a reasonably boring job. Many of the calls that I went to, usually talking, there was some substance abuse difficulty, alcohol or psychological well being points. So the commander was completely appropriate. These parts existed. And so they have been often for small property crimes, petty disagreements between neighbors that might be dealt with contained in the neighborhood. And so whereas there was no outlined quota in any of the companies that I ever labored at, is simply that we knew that the administration was going to begin leaning on us if we weren’t producing tickets, if we weren’t making arrests. Properly, the place would we go to try this? We’d go sit in a poor neighborhood, look forward to any individual in a junkie automotive drive by, who might have an expired tag, or a headlight out, a taillight out, and go on these fishing expeditions. After which we’d discover any individual with a little bit little bit of weed. Or they possibly have a suspended license, which have been nearly all the time, by the way in which, as a result of they have been poor and had an unpaid visitors ticket or weren’t capable of pay for his or her insurance coverage. That put numbers on the spreadsheet. My very first division was all the way in which out within the boonies. And it was only a small division with 5 folks. I imply, you’ll simply go a few shifts and never get one name for service. So all the things that we did was, quote unquote, “proactive policing.” Properly, then, over the following 13 years, I labored for the biggest division in Indiana, the second or third largest division in South Carolina. It was the identical factor. It was simply this absolute overemphasis on these petty crimes, whereas main crimes have been going uninvestigated.
Proper, I believe that we see a lot of what policing has seemed like, which is in regards to the criminalization of poverty. I believe it’s essential to notice right here that that is one thing that I need to emphasize that police and justice impacts everybody with the instances of somebody like Daniel Shaver, who was shot to loss of life whereas crying on the ground, or Tony Timpa, who’s held down by police whereas they laughed on physique cam, and the way a lot of that is the policing of poverty and the policing of what we predict police are speculated to be doing just isn’t what they’re doing. And so, Rashawn, I need to hear from you. You’ve completed a lot work on this. What are your prime priorities in the case of reforming policing?
Yeah, so I began out on this work by doing numerous work with legislation enforcement, coaching them on implicit bias, coaching them on de-escalation, growing this revolutionary digital actuality program. However what I rapidly realized is that that’s restricted as a result of a few of the issues that Randy’s speaking about are a few of the minute issues that legislation enforcement can’t management, like coaching and even possibly how they reply to sure issues the place, actually, what I began noticing is that while you observe the cash and while you observe the coverage, what you notice is that oftentimes municipalities are lifted up by the issues that Randy talked about, these low degree citations. That’s how we bought Ferguson, proper? That’s how we ended up with the loss of life of Michael Brown. So what all of this led me to is while you observe the cash, simply over the previous 5 years, within the main 20 metropolitan areas in the USA, taxpayers have paid out over $2 billion with a B in settlements for police misconduct. Oftentimes, persons are paying for their very own brutality, so exterior of police budgets, which have swelled over the previous three a long time. I imply, you’ve gotten all the things from over 40 % in Oakland to nicely over 35 % in cities like Chicago and Minneapolis, that these civilian payouts don’t even come from the police price range. And what it led me to is that if we had police division insurance coverage insurance policies, if we had extra police officer malpractice particular person legal responsibility insurance coverage, we’d see not solely a shift in monetary culpability, but additionally a shift in accountability. And so, a part of how it might function could be just like what occurs in healthcare, that in healthcare, hospitals have insurance coverage, physicians have insurance coverage. Regulation enforcement officers should be above reproach. Much like pilots, they should be good, or else, folks die. And so a part of this shift, since most locations are small, they already are a part of insurance coverage danger swimming pools, comparable to small departments in east Tennessee or exterior of Los Angeles, the place officers which have been eliminated have change into uninsurable as a result of they’ve engaged in misconduct. Departments have really closed as a result of insurance coverage danger swimming pools have stated, we will now not afford to maintain you right here. You realize what? That helps to handle dangerous apples that come from rotten timber. See, we restrict issues to dangerous apples, not realizing that it’s a course of. They arrive from someplace. And so they come from rotten timber in legislation enforcement. And the roots are embedded in white supremacy ideology that oftentimes we’re unwilling to confess. The opposite factor, good apples can’t merely override dangerous apples. Sure, overwhelmingly, officers get into it as a result of they need to shield and serve. However we simply heard from Randy what occurs in that course of. Good apples change into poisoned. And so they can also at instances change into rotten themselves. As a result of a part of what occurs is that they get swallowed up within the system. And attributable to certified immunity, they’re utterly alleviated from any kind of monetary culpability. And I believe insurances could be a enormous strategy to enhance accountability.
However would you say that a part of the issue here’s what police are being requested to do within the first place? As an illustration, the F.B.I. studies that in 2019, throughout the U.S, 45.5 % of violent crimes, together with murder, aggravated assault, rape, and theft, have been cleared. And by cleared, they imply somebody bought arrested, or the case was closed for another purpose. So plainly a part of that is, sure, there must be accountability for the dangerous apples and for all of the apples. However what are the apples being requested to do within the first place?
So there are two issues taking place. First, legislation enforcement is requested to unravel our society’s social issues with power. And it’s not proper. A part of the opposite factor that occurs is that every one calls about something below the solar, from a cat being up in a tree to a pothole to a homicide, is available in a 911. And we deploy police and appearing like they’ve the skillset to have the ability to deal with all of these kind of responses. So oftentimes, they’re being arrange for failure as a result of they overly prepare towards use of power techniques and worst case situations, as an alternative of the over 90 % of instances which can be non-violent and don’t have anything to do with power in any respect. What do you count on for them to do once they’re in a worrying scenario? They reply with what they’ve been skilled to do probably the most. So a part of what now we have to suppose by means of is healthier options. And what the analysis I’ve carried out suggests is that if we reallocate a few of these requires service, not solely are there higher folks within the social service sector, comparable to psychological well being specialists or Division of Transportation higher geared up to deal with these issues, but additionally cops can then deal with the extra violent crimes and growing that clearance price.
Not solely is there this overemphasis about power, however after we take a look at how are cops skilled to unravel crimes, the way to examine crimes, a small portion of their primary coaching is surrounding the way to examine crimes. Once you’re despatched to extra superior faculties, we checked out the entire superior coaching right here within the state of California, so murder coaching, sexual assault investigation coaching, housebreaking, theft, automotive thefts: These are programs which can be two weeks or much less. I used to be an investigator as a licensed fireplace and explosion investigator, which feels like a extremely cool title. I went to 2 weeks of faculty to get this after which later, discovered about junk science and forensics, which is an entire different episode. However what I noticed is that we’re locking folks up. We’re not getting justice for households, particularly justice for people who find themselves victims of violent crime, just because the prioritizations of the police division is wrong. And the officers are simply not ready in coaching to have the ability to examine these crimes.
Ash, we began speaking about reallocating sources. And I noticed your eyes gentle up a little bit bit. Are you able to speak about how you concentrate on options? You’ve been a proponent of defunding police, which is one thing folks have heard so much, however aren’t actually certain of how it might work conceptually. Are you able to stroll us by means of what that might seem like and the way you got here to that place?
Yeah. I imply, I believe lovingly, I got here to this place as a result of we’ve been placing platinum bandaids and piecemeal reforms into place. And it hasn’t made policing any higher for Black folks or poor folks or immigrant folks, proper? Once we speak about defunding the police, we’re not simply speaking in regards to the sheriff in your county or the P.D. in your inside metropolis neighborhood. We’re speaking in regards to the state police. We’re speaking about Capitol police who we actually watched hand-walk insurrectionists out of the Capitol on January 6. We’re speaking about immigrant communities which can be impacted by I.C.E., proper? We’re speaking about Customs and Border Patrol. We’re speaking in regards to the navy interventions that power migrants to return to this nation within the first place, solely to then be policed for being right here, proper? And so I simply need to be clear. The one answer isn’t to proceed to try to reform a system that’s working precisely because it was designed to, proper? Policing just isn’t damaged on this nation. It’s actually designed to work on this approach. Policing on this nation makes folks cash. Incarceration on this nation makes folks cash. The one answer to that’s to abolish it. So, as a lot as I hear the hope of hurt discount and what Randy and Rashawn say, my query is, is like, OK, and if that doesn’t work and three folks every single day are murdered by cops, then what? So for me, once I hear “defund the police,” what I hear is the start of a dialog. What I heard was an acknowledgment of the righteous rage, proper, the deep grief and the abiding and contagious love of Black people who have had sufficient of the cumulative loss of life of Black folks by the hands of the police that needed to do one thing about it. What I additionally hear typically in response to the defund demand is, like, that’s cute, Ash-Lee. Love you, sis, however that’s unattainable. How will we hold folks secure if we defund the police? However I wager if I requested you, Jane or Rashawn or Randy, to shut your eyes and inform me a time the place you felt secure, what did it really feel like, you wouldn’t inform me that there was a cop there. And if it was, it might most likely be as a result of that cop might need been your dad or your mother or your aunt or your uncle, proper? Not as a result of they have been of their uniform in a cop automotive policing any individual else. So fairly frankly, I believe the one answer to policing on this nation is abolition. And the way will we get there by means of divestment and funding is basically tremendous clear.
Ash, you stated that policing was working because it was designed. However my thought is, do you see the potential to revamp it, what policing might be in the best possible model of it? For instance, I do know that I’ve known as the police twice in my life. I known as the police as soon as when there have been folks in our yard, and I used to be on my own. And I didn’t know who they have been or what was occurring. And I used to be very scared, and that was the very first thing I assumed to do as a result of I assumed I ought to most likely not confront these folks. Unhealthy concept. And the second time was when I discovered a person who had handed out. There was a police officer a couple of block away as a result of I lived in a neighborhood the place police simply frolicked on the nook to only see what was taking place for causes one would possibly assume. And in each of these cases, I felt as if that is an entity that isn’t me, that’s somebody who will present a solution of some type. Can’t we simply redetermine what police do?
I imply, I hear it as an possibility, proper? I hear it’s an possibility, a logical possibility. [LAUGHS] I’m intellectually perceive it.
I’m actually appreciative, very appreciative.
I do, I actually do. I imply, I get it, proper? It’s like, there are issues. Hurt occurs, proper? However often, when cops are known as, it’s to not eradicate the world of hurt. It’s as a result of hurt has already occurred. And they’re known as in to punish the individual. Now if what we all know is the criminalization on this nation is racialized and gendered and rooted in a category hierarchy, then if they’re being known as in to punish somebody for hurt, that hurt might be related to this racist, patriarchal, elitist understanding of what hurt is within the first place, proper? So might we reside in a world, Jane, the place cops now not are weaponized in a strategy to punish folks for harms that shouldn’t be probably unlawful within the first place? Like, certain, some persons are arguing that these are options. However what I’d argue is these are platinum bandaids. Let’s return to Rashawn’s metaphor. If policing is the rotten tree with white supremacist roots that’s producing rotten fruit, then why would we proceed to place bandaids on the rotten apples and a hope that the distinctive good fruit will likely be produced, versus taking the sources that we’re spending on these platinum bandaids and placing them into neighborhood options, proper? It’s like often when folks inform me that abolition is unattainable, they are saying as a result of there isn’t actually an alternative choice to policing. There are often 3 times the place folks inform me we will’t — three or 4, 4 instances — let’s say 4 — the place there are not any various to what we should be doing in our communities if there weren’t police, proper? It’s if somebody’s in a psychological well being disaster, who handles visitors stops, what occurs if there’s violent crime, and what occurs in a world the place there nonetheless is gender-based violence, proper? If we’re speaking about psychological well being providers, police are extra probably to make use of deadly power when an individual is experiencing psychiatric misery. If we’re speaking about visitors providers, one of many providers that police commonly present to our communities, right here’s an space once more the place armed uniformed police are completely pointless, proper? If we’re speaking about violent crime, our widespread chorus in opposition to defunding the police assumes that our society received’t be capable to successfully reply to it. However now we have to do not forget that police don’t forestall violence. In most incidents of violent crime, police are responding to a criminal offense that’s already taken place. And when this occurs, what we want from police is a service that we’ll examine the crime and maybe forestall such crimes from occurring sooner or later. However policing is definitely sick, if in any respect, geared up to go well with these wants. Do I believe that we will reform our approach out of the disaster of policing on this nation? I don’t. And I don’t as a result of I’ve seen so many instances us strive. I’ve seen us say that if we simply skilled them extra, it might be completely different. I’ve seen us say, if we simply banned no-knock warrants, it might be completely different. I’ve seen us say, if we simply bought physique cams on these cops, which is increasingly more and more cash going to policing, however what we’ve seen is that that hasn’t distracted or detracted them as a result of they’ll proceed to make use of affordable power as their get out of jail and accountability-free card. So I simply don’t imagine that the info reveals that reforming our approach out of policing is maintaining Black folks free and alive.
Rawshawn, I believe I noticed you wanting to reply right here. What do you suppose?
I believe what Ash is basically getting at, to construct on her profound statements of placing platinum bandaids on deep unhealed wounds, it’s fairly profound. Look, can we reside in a world the place legislation enforcement doesn’t exist? Certain, however so as to take action, now we have to handle societal issues that cops are anticipated to cope with versus these they’re anticipated to forestall, like weapons. So after we take a look at and we examine the USA to different industrialized nations, do they nonetheless expertise racial brutality and racial profiling? Sure, however they don’t expertise the extent of police killings. Why? As a result of weapons will not be as accessible to the general public or to cops. And that is the opposite factor. After I take into consideration abolition, folks thought that ending slavery was one thing that might by no means occur. Individuals thought that ending segregation was one thing that might by no means occur. However what? They did. However what additionally survived these historic intervals? Regulation enforcement. You realize why? As a result of legislation enforcement is the gatekeeper of legalized state sanctioned violence. Regulation enforcement abolition most likely requires a revolution we haven’t seen earlier than. A part of what abolitionists additionally need — as a result of I believe there are two major camps. There are some which can be like, legislation enforcement shouldn’t exist. Prisons shouldn’t exist. There are others who’re like, look, we have to reimagine it. Like these rotten timber, we have to lower it down. Once you cope with a rotten tree or a rotten plant, merely reducing it down doesn’t make it go away. The roots come again, proper? And oftentimes, the plant comes again stronger. And curiously, it comes again in a unique type, prefer it’s wrapped in a unique package deal. And so, however there are some individuals who say, how about we handle abolition from the standpoint of abolishing police departments as they at the moment stand and reimagining and rebuilding public security in a approach that’s completely different? See, even the terminology we use is basically essential — policing, legislation enforcement, public security. A part of reimagining legislation enforcement is reimagining the phrases we use for what security means. And the way I give it some thought is, who has the best to actually specific their First Modification proper and be verbally and/or nonviolently expressive? It’s not unlawful to be combative.
Proper, it’s not unlawful to curse. In the event you’re from the South, it may not be a morally proper factor to do. Or if you happen to’re a extremely spiritual individual —
I encourage to vary. Southerners are one of the best cussers. [LAUGHTER]
Properly, sure, certain. However total, folks, it’s oftentimes some cultural variations there, proper? And pondering by means of that, that’s not unlawful. An individual shouldn’t be brutalized for that. An individual shouldn’t be killed for that. However who we discovered that that does have the best to try this? White folks, and notably, white girls. They oftentimes — cops don’t reply to them. They really get extra deferential when white girls increase their voices at them and cuss at them. With Black girls, they do the precise reverse. They get extra aggressive. They escalate power. Yet one more fast factor. Just lately obtained a grant from the Russell Sage Basis with some colleagues on the College of North Carolina. We’re inspecting the function that Black Lives Matter protests in cities have on native police reform. And we’re going by means of newspaper clips. And one in all my colleagues was studying a clip. And he was saying, yeah, we want extra police surveillance. We have to make it possible for we watch what they’re doing. We’d like extra coaching. This clip was from the Eighties, nearly across the similar time the place Ash was speaking about she was born. So right here we’re, constantly utilizing the phrases “police reform,” appearing like it really works. And it doesn’t. We’d like transformation. We’d like reimagining. Cops can not try this. They don’t have the skillset to do it. And that’s the approach now we have to consider this. [MUSIC PLAYING]
- listener voicemail
Hey, Jane. My title is Josh. And I reside in New York. And the factor I’ve been arguing about with my professors is the two-party system. I see it as simply a particularly limiting system that individuals don’t match properly into. You possibly can ask any Democrat or a Republican. And more often than not, I’ve by no means been capable of finding somebody who utterly aligns with one occasion’s platform. They only type of select that one as a result of that’s one of many solely two choices they’ve. Thanks.
What are you arguing about with your loved ones, your pals, your frenemies? Inform me in regards to the large debate you’re having in a voicemail by calling 347-915-4324. And we would play an excerpt of it on a future episode.
So, Randy, I believe that is the right time so that you can speak about the truth that police will not be skilled for this. That’s one thing you’ve actually targeted on. The kind of policing that I grew up watching on “Regulation and Order,” that simply doesn’t occur. [SHREWSBERRY LAUGHS] What do you consider the divestment argument?
Certain, so I’m not in disagreement with Ash or Dr. Ray. I believe that is one thing that we have to reimagine. The place I’m most likely a little bit to the best is that I view it as workable, however a really lengthy street. And so the query is, is, what will we do within the meantime? And right here’s the difficulty from a coaching perspective is that we need to create a twenty first century curriculum, one which has a deal with primary is instructing officers the historic context of policing and why we have to make a change, one which has a deal with criminology, so cops have an understanding of what are the social impacts that trigger crime within the first place. After which the best emphasis is on fixing crimes, as an alternative of, A, attempting to forestall them, which we all know the police don’t do, or responding to minor calls that may be dealt with by unarmed of us. So, at first is what now we have to do on this curriculum is develop it to officers get about six months of coaching to cowl about 60 matters. And a 3rd of that’s largely round use of power. Once we take a look at worldwide counterparts, solely Iraq, Afghanistan, for whom we prepare their police, and Papua New Guinea have decrease requirements than the U.S. So our view is that we will fulfill the guarantees of higher coaching. We will fulfill the guarantees of reimagining policing or public security that doesn’t should be a punitive solely method.
The USA taxpayer is actually requested to foot this unattainable and unending invoice to keep up this failed system of policing, proper? I need to pull a little bit bit on Randy’s final level and what Dr. Ray raised about weapons as nicely. It’s like even Forbes, I believe, final week talked about that a couple of mass capturing per day has occurred in 2021. And so if cops hold me secure from gun violence, this stat wouldn’t be actual, proper? So if cops have been maintaining Black folks secure from gun violence, the world will likely be a really completely different place. And I doubt we’d be having this dialog within the first place. We’ve bought to really be revolutionary past the request for assist for more cash for extra trainings, for extra know-how. And so, fairly frankly, after we take into consideration what’s taking place on the federal degree legislatively proper now with the Justice and Policing Act, I believe the motion for Black — nicely, not I believe — I do know the motion for Black Lives unequivocally doesn’t assist it. As a result of, once more, it’s an try at 1990 options to a 2021 drawback. The Justice and Policing Act bans no-knock warrants and chokeholds in drug instances. It provides information transparency provisions. It gives some oversight for the native procurement and navy gear by police. It adjustments the federal use of power commonplace to solely when needed, as an alternative of reasonableness. And it ends certified immunity for native and federal legislation enforcement officers. But it surely’s a flawed framework. It depends on a flawed root trigger evaluation and inaccurate concept of change. Two, it doesn’t defund. After which, three, it’s cops overseeing cops. After which, lastly, physique cameras, trainings, ineffective coverage options that enhance police budgets are embedded all all through the invoice. So if I used to be doing a aspect by aspect, I’d say if that’s the false answer, that the precise neighborhood invested answer is the Breathe Act, proper? The federal omnibus invoice that the Motion for Black Lives wrote because the legislative love letter to the oldsters that have been within the streets in 2020, demanding “defund the police.” If the Justice and Policing Act places more cash in policing, the Breathe Act divests from the federal grants and companies which can be primarily funding legislation enforcement within the carceral state. And so, of us can take a look at extra data on the Breathe Act at breatheact.org. And that is our alternative to make dramatic change years within the making.
Properly, I do know that we might clearly speak about this for a number of days. I simply need to say thanks a lot for bringing your concepts and for the work that you simply’re all doing on this. I believe that that is — it’s a extremely difficult topic for thus many causes as a result of it’s so private. And since I believe it’s so advanced and sophisticated. It includes numerous discussions about the way in which we would like the world to be and the way in which the world is. And I simply actually recognize your time.
This was nice. So good to see you all, and I’m trying ahead to constructing with you quickly.
Thanks a lot for having us on. This was such a robust and essential dialog about how we rework policing in America. [MUSIC PLAYING]
If you wish to be taught extra about police reform, I like to recommend studying the textual content of the George Floyd Justice and Policing Act of 2021. I additionally suggest The New York Instances Journal piece that contains a roundtable of specialists and organizers. It’s known as, “The message is evident: policing in America is damaged and should change. However how?” You will discover hyperlinks to all of those in our episode notes. Lastly, I need to suggest the guide, “Ghettoside, A True Story of Homicide in America,” by Jill Leovy for an enchanting historical past of how policing has labored, or, extra precisely, hasn’t labored in main cities for many years. To cite Leovy, “As a rustic, now we have by no means been superb on the type of thorough knowledgeable investigations that result in swift arrest to render avenue justice moot.”
The Argument is manufacturing of New York Instances Opinion. It’s produced by Phoebe Lett, Elisa Gutierrez, and Vishakha Darbha, edited by Alison Bruzek and Paula Szuchman, with unique music and sound design by Isaac Jones, and fact-checking by Kate Sinclair. Particular thanks this week to Laura Juncadella,